When is a poor person justified in seeking more than the usual tzedakah amount?

A poor person is justified in seeking more than the usual tzedakah amount during emergencies or dire situations due to the fundamental principle of Torah obligation to help those in dire need. In such times, the urgency of the person's plight may require greater assistance than what is normally provided, as their survival, health, or safety could be at stake.

Tzedakah, or charitable giving, is not only about meeting basic needs but also responding compassionately and adequately to severe circumstances. In emergencies, the typical expectations or norms surrounding tzedakah may be overridden by the immediate necessity to provide for a life-threatening or critical situation.

The other context options do not necessarily align with the urgent ethical imperative that governs our obligations to support those in extreme distress. While seeking help only when necessary or in specific forums may seem prudent, they do not address the immediacy that comes with emergencies, which calls for a more generous approach. Similarly, limiting requests for more help only to the presence of wealthy individuals fails to take into account the nature of the dire situation, where every available resource must be considered to alleviate suffering effectively.